---
title: Ruling in Guindon will likely mean more tax preparer penalties | Counter Tax Litigators LLP
description: The Supreme Court's recent Guindon ruling that administrative monetary penalties do not offend constitutional rights will likely have a “chilling” effect.
image: https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Thinking/countertax-thinking-2015-08-06.png
---

[Skip to content](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/ruling-in-guindon-will-likely-mean-more-tax-preparer-penalties/#main-content)

 Search Articles

- There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

Open main navigation

Close main navigation

- [Capabilities](https://www.countertax.ca/capabilities)
- Insights
  
  Show submenu for Insights
- [Case Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/case-studies)
- About
  
  Show submenu for About
- [Contact](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)

[![Counter Tax Litigators LLP](https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Imagery/CounterTax-logo.svg) ](https://www.countertax.ca/)

- [Capabilities](https://www.countertax.ca/capabilities)
- [Insights](https://www.countertax.ca/insights)
  
  Show submenu for Insights
- [Case Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/case-studies)
- [About](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/overview/institutional-history)
  
  Show submenu for About
- [Contact](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)

Open main navigation

Close main navigation

- [Capabilities](https://www.countertax.ca/capabilities)
- Insights
  
  Show submenu for Insights
- [Case Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/case-studies)
- About
  
  Show submenu for About
- [Contact](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)

![CounterTax](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Counter%20Tax%20Litigators%20Logo%20Stacked%20(MidnightBlue%20on%20White).jpg?width=120&name=Counter%20Tax%20Litigators%20Logo%20Stacked%20(MidnightBlue%20on%20White).jpg)

[Back to Insights](https://www.countertax.ca/insights)

### Related Insights

- [CRA Settlement After a Reassessment: When Resolution Becomes Unstable](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-settlement-after-a-reassessment-when-cra-keeps-pulling-the-file-back)
- [Dispute Record Risk at CRA Reassessment](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-dispute-record-risk)
- [Notice of Objection Failed to Define the Dispute](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-notice-of-objection-appea-limits)

# Ruling in Guindon will likely mean more tax preparer penalties

By  Counter Tax Litigators LLP

Share

- [![](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/images/linkedin-blue.png?width=20&name=linkedin-blue.png) LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://www.countertax.ca/insights/ruling-in-guindon-will-likely-mean-more-tax-preparer-penalties/)
- [ X](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https://www.countertax.ca/insights/ruling-in-guindon-will-likely-mean-more-tax-preparer-penalties/&text=)
- [email Email](mailto:info@countertax.ca?&subject=&cc=&bcc=&body=https://www.countertax.ca/insights/ruling-in-guindon-will-likely-mean-more-tax-preparer-penalties/)

Print

![Ruling in Guindon will likely mean more tax preparer penalties](https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Thinking/countertax-thinking-2015-08-06.png)

Ruling in Guindon will likely mean more tax preparer penalties

4:31

##### ![countertax-media-2015-08-04-LF.jpg](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Media/countertax-media-2015-08-04-LF.jpg?width=320&name=countertax-media-2015-08-04-LF.jpg)

The Supreme Court of Canada's recent ruling that administrative monetary penalties do not offend constitutional rights will likely have a “chilling” effect on tax advisers, Toronto tax litigation lawyer [Peter Aprile](https://www.countertax.ca/team/peter-aprile) tells [Legal Feeds](http://www.canadianlawyermag.com/legalfeeds/2825/cra-likely-to-impose-more-adviser-penalties-in-light-of-scc-decision.html)*.*

As the article notes, *[Guindon v. Canada](http://scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/15478/index.do) *dealt with adviser penalties assessed against lawyer Julie Guindon under [s. 163.2 of the Income Tax Act](http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/I-3.3/page-290.html#docCont). The section imposes penalties on anyone who makes false statements that could be used by another person for the purpose of the act.

In 2001, Guindon gave a legal opinion about the Global Trust Charitable Donation Program, but, as the decision says, she had not reviewed the supporting documents.

The program involved a tax reduction scheme that involved the donation of vacation ownership weeks in a timeshare, but as the SCC notes, “The scheme was a sham: no timeshare units were created and no transfers from the donors to the charity occurred.”

The CRA assessed adviser penalties of $546,747 against Guindon, but she argued that “the penalty imposed under s. 163.2(4) is criminal and that she is therefore a person ‘charged with an offence’ who is entitled to the procedural safeguards provided for in [s.11](https://zoupio.lexum.com/calegis/schedule-b-to-the-canada-act-1982-uk-1982-c-11-en#!fragment/sec11) of the *[Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms](https://zoupio.lexum.com/calegis/schedule-b-to-the-canada-act-1982-uk-1982-c-11-en).”*

She contended that the matter should not have proceeded in the Tax Court of Canada and that the penalty should be vacated. She was successful in the Tax Court, but the Federal Court of Appeal set that decision aside.

However, the SCC ruled last week that proceedings under [s. 163.2](https://zoupio.lexum.com/calegis/rsc-1985-c-1-5th-supp-en#!fragment/sec163.2) are of an administrative nature, rather than criminal — which means Guindon must now pay the assessed penalties.

Aprile, principal of Counter Tax Lawyers, tells Legal Feeds that it was interesting to listen to the statements the CRA was making at various accounting conferences as the case moved through the Tax Court, and then the Federal Court of Appeal.

“We know the CRA wanted to get the word out there about the possibility of substantial fines being levied in the civil context without having to cross over to criminal prosecution,” he says.

Counter Tax Lawyers filed an access to information request just before the Federal Court of Appeal released its decision, the article reports, in order to determine how many penalties the CRA had issued.

In March 2013, Aprile's access to information request revealed the CRA had issued 77 s. 163.2 penalties to tax preparers, planners, and promoters totalling approximately $119.5 million. There were 47 ongoing audits and 14 of those involved tax preparers and 33 were tax promoters.

“As at April 11, 2014, the CRA approved 93 proposals to assess the penalty and chose not to issue assessments related to 21 s. 163.2 penalties. As at May 2011, 19 promoters and 27 tax preparers had been assessed $65.5 million, and audits of 52 promoters and 23 preparers were underway. No penalties had been reversed at the objection stage,” according to the access to information request, Legal Feeds reports.

Between 2000 and 2007, says the article, the CRA had only issued nine assessments. Between the Federal Court of Appeal decision and the SCC decision in *Guindon*, the numbers jumped to $137 million in penalties, and all assessments were stuck at the objection level.

As the 2014 Auditor's General report indicates, the median penalty issued is $440,000.

This data shows that two things are happening, Aprile says in the article. “The CRA has held every other one in abeyance pending resolution of *Guindon*, and so we will start seeing those move through the courts. And it’s obvious with the Federal Court of Appeal decision, the CRA gained some confidence it would stand the test of the Supreme Court.

Aprile says he has little doubt there will be greater imposition of these penalties, as well as more activity in the court "to determine what rises to the level of culpable conduct and what an appropriate due diligence defence will look like.

“I think the CRA is using the threat of this as a pretty good tool to change behaviour even in instances in which behaviour shouldn’t or doesn’t need to be changed,” he says.

For additional analysis, see our [Insights](https://www.countertax.ca/insights).

## Insights

[![CRA Settlement After a Reassessment: When Resolution Becomes Unstable | Zhang v. HMK illustrates how resolution may not be treated as final inside the institution](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/CRA%20Settlement%20After%20a%20Reassessment%20When%20Resolution%20Becomes%20Unstable.png?width=499&height=299&name=CRA%20Settlement%20After%20a%20Reassessment%20When%20Resolution%20Becomes%20Unstable.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-settlement-after-a-reassessment-when-cra-keeps-pulling-the-file-back)

### [CRA Settlement After a Reassessment: When Resolution Becomes Unstable](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-settlement-after-a-reassessment-when-cra-keeps-pulling-the-file-back)

*Tax Court of Canada decision on CRA settlement after reassessment, showing how accepted settlement terms may not end the dispute when CRA and DOJ continue pulling the file back. (Zhang v HMK)*

[![](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Dispute%20Record%20Risk%20at%20CRA%20Reassessment.png?width=499&height=299&name=Dispute%20Record%20Risk%20at%20CRA%20Reassessment.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-dispute-record-risk)

### [Dispute Record Risk at CRA Reassessment](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-dispute-record-risk)

*A CRA reassessment and dispute do not start from a neutral position. They shape the dispute, now and later. This article explains how the record develops and the impact on teh range of outcomes. *

[![Notice of Objection Failed to Define the Dispute | Some objection-stage failures are obvious. Others remain invisible and lead to the same result. (941624 Alberta Ltd. v. HMK) ](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/2026-04-20%20Notice%20of%20Objection%20Failed%20to%20Define%20the%20Dispute.png?width=499&height=299&name=2026-04-20%20Notice%20of%20Objection%20Failed%20to%20Define%20the%20Dispute.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-notice-of-objection-appea-limits)

### [Notice of Objection Failed to Define the Dispute](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-notice-of-objection-appea-limits)

*CRA reassessment and notice of objection. Large corporation regime. How a failure to define the dispute can stop an appeal early or narrow what can be argued later.*

[![Cross-Border Rental & Withholding Reassessment Control - When the structure holds, and where it can still be moved -  C&W Offshore Ltd. v. HMK ](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Cross-Border%20Rental%20%26%20Withholding%20Reassessment%20Control.png?width=499&height=299&name=Cross-Border%20Rental%20%26%20Withholding%20Reassessment%20Control.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cross-border-rental-withholding-tax-reassessment)

### [Cross-Border Rental & Withholding Reassessment Control](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cross-border-rental-withholding-tax-reassessment)

*A cross-border equipment rental led to a withholding tax reassessment under Part XIII. This case shows how much of the exposure can still be reduced when the structure holds.*

[![DAC Investment Holdings and the Widening Lens on Tax Regime Integrity](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/DAC%20Investment%20Holdings%20and%20the%20Widening%20Lens%20on%20Tax%20Regime%20Integrity.png?width=499&height=299&name=DAC%20Investment%20Holdings%20and%20the%20Widening%20Lens%20on%20Tax%20Regime%20Integrity.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/dac-fca-gaar-ccpc)

### [DAC Investment Holdings and the Widening Lens on Tax Regime Integrity](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/dac-fca-gaar-ccpc)

*Federal Court of Appeal decision in DAC Investment Holdings (2026 FCA 35) shows how GAAR disputes can turn on tax regime integrity rather than individual provisions.*

[![Bakorp Confirms That Large Corporation Objections Define the Outcome | How subsection 165(1.11) limited the appeal before the tax issue was ever examined](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Bakorp%20Confirms%20That%20Large%20Corporation%20Objections%20Define%20the%20Outcome.png?width=499&height=299&name=Bakorp%20Confirms%20That%20Large%20Corporation%20Objections%20Define%20the%20Outcome.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/bakorp-large-corporation-objection-limits)

### [Bakorp Confirms That Large Corporation Objections Define the Outcome](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/bakorp-large-corporation-objection-limits)

*In Bakorp, the FCA held that subsection 165(1.11) confines a large corporation’s appeal to the issues specified in its Notice of Objection, dismissing the case without reviewing the tax merits.*

[ Explore more insights > ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights)

- Capabilities 
    - [Capabilities Overview](https://www.countertax.ca/capabilities)
- Insights 
    - [Insights Overview](https://www.countertax.ca/insights)
    - [CRA Dispute Decision Points](https://www.countertax.ca/cra-dispute-decision-points)
    - [Tax Dispute Caselaw & Signals](https://www.countertax.ca/tax-dispute-caselaw-signals)
    - [Foundations](https://www.countertax.ca/foundations)
    - [Case Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/case-studies)
    - [Institute for Tax Controversy Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/institute/overview)
- About 
    - [About Overview](https://www.countertax.ca/institute/about-us)
    - [History](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/overview/institutional-history)
    - [Partners](https://www.countertax.ca/partners)
    - [Governance & Standards](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/overview/governance)
    - [The Work](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/overview/standard-of-the-work)
    - [Recognition](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/recognition)

##### Contact

[Begin here](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)

[![Counter-Newsletter-linkedin-icon-navy-lg](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Counter_Tax/email/Counter-Newsletter-linkedin-icon-navy-lg.png?width=34&height=34&name=Counter-Newsletter-linkedin-icon-navy-lg.png)](https://www.linkedin.com/company/counter-tax-lawyers/)

##### Subscribe to receive CRA reassessment and dispute insights

 © Counter Tax Litigators 2026

- Chambers Global
- Chambers Canada
- International Tax Review

- [Contact](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)
- [Terms of Use](https://www.countertax.ca/terms-of-use)
- [Privacy Policy](https://www.countertax.ca/privacy-policy)
- [Disclaimer](https://www.countertax.ca/disclaimer)

![](https://px.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=6846258&fmt=gif)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP",
    "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca/insights/author/counter"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-04-30T14:39:14.596Z",
  "datePublished" : "2015-08-06T14:37:00.000Z",
  "headline" : "Ruling in Guindon will likely mean more tax preparer penalties",
  "image" : [ "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Thinking/countertax-thinking-2015-08-06.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.countertax.ca/insights/ruling-in-guindon-will-likely-mean-more-tax-preparer-penalties/",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Branding/countertax-logo-white.svg"
    },
    "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators"
  }
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@id" : "https://www.countertax.ca/#legalservice",
  "@type" : [ "LegalService", "Organization" ],
  "address" : {
    "@type" : "PostalAddress",
    "addressCountry" : "CA",
    "addressLocality" : "Toronto",
    "addressRegion" : "ON",
    "postalCode" : "M4V 3A9",
    "streetAddress" : "301–10 Alcorn Avenue"
  },
  "alternateName" : "Counter LLP",
  "award" : [ "Included in ITR World Tax 2026 Tax Controversy Rankings", "Recognized in Chambers Canada 2026 for Tax Litigation", "Recognized among Canada's Top Tax Law Boutiques by Canadian Lawyer (2025–2026)", "Recognized in ITR World Tax 2025 Rankings for Tax Controversy (Canada)", "Finalist for Tax Innovator of the Year by International Tax Review" ],
  "description" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP acts exclusively for private companies in material judgment-driven CRA disputes. Engagement begins at reassessment and operates through resolution.",
  "founder" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.countertax.ca/partners/peter-aprile#person",
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Peter Aprile",
    "sameAs" : [ "https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q139586811", "https://www.linkedin.com/in/peteraprile", "https://chambers.com/lawyer/peter-aprile-global-2:25392815" ],
    "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca/partners/peter-aprile"
  },
  "image" : [ {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/CRA%20Objection%20Strategy%20Article.jpg",
    "description" : "Explore key considerations for selecting the most effective approach to the CRA’s objection process, balancing full engagement with strategic disengagement.",
    "name" : "CRA’s Objection Process: Full Engagement vs. Strategic Disengagement"
  }, {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Winning%20Settlements%20in%20CRA%20Tax%20Disputes%20Article.jpg",
    "description" : "Strategic settlement design aligns client goals with legal principles to achieve superior outcomes.",
    "name" : "Winning Settlements: Aligning Client Goals with Legal Strategy."
  }, {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Comprehensive%20Analysis%20of%20Income%20Tax%20Penalties%20Article.jpg",
    "description" : "A Comprehensive Analysis of Income Tax Penalties, clarity and superior tax dispute results provided by Counter Tax Litigators LLP.",
    "name" : "A Comprehensive Analysis of Income Tax Penalties"
  }, {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Overturning%20CRA%20Non-Resident%20Trusts.jpg",
    "description" : "Read Canada’s trusted guide to addressing CRA challenges to non-resident trusts, published by Counter Tax Litigators LLP x Thomson Reuters.",
    "name" : "Overturning CRA Decisions on Non-Resident Trusts"
  }, {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Corporate%20Residence%20Article%20Image.jpg",
    "description" : "Canada’s leading guide on complex corporate residence disputes, published by CounterTax Litigators LLP x Thomson Reuters.",
    "name" : "A Comprehensive Guide to Corporate Residence and Disputes in Canada"
  } ],
  "knowsAbout" : [ "Tax litigation", "Tax controversy", "CRA disputes", "Tax reassessments", "Objection-stage tax disputes", "Tax appeals" ],
  "legalName" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP",
  "logo" : {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Counter%20Tax%20Litigators%20Logo%20Stacked%20(MidnightBlue%20on%20White).jpg",
    "description" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP logo with tagline, emphasizing expertise in tax litigation.",
    "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators Logo"
  },
  "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP",
  "sameAs" : [ "https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q139032486", "https://www.linkedin.com/company/counter-tax-litigators/", "https://chambers.com/law-firm/counter-tax-litigators-llp-canada-20:22876595", "https://www.itrworldtax.com/Firm/Counter-Tax-Litigators-Canada/Profile/39298", "https://www.legal500.com/firms/240684-counter-tax-litigators-llp/239668-toronto-canada/" ],
  "telephone" : "+1-416-218-5263",
  "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca/"
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@id" : "https://www.countertax.ca/#website",
  "@type" : "WebSite",
  "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators",
  "potentialAction" : {
    "@type" : "SearchAction",
    "query-input" : "required name=search_term_string",
    "target" : "https://www.countertax.ca/search-results?q={search_term_string}"
  },
  "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca"
}
```