---
title: Decision reining in taxman’s penalties cheered | Counter Tax Litigators LLP
description: The Tax Court of Canada has determined that the often “harsh” penalties imposed on taxpayers who misreport income in two out of four years cannot be imposed if due diligence is exercised in at least one of those years.
image: https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Thinking/countertax-thinking-2014-10-03.png
---

[Skip to content](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/decision-reining-in-taxmans-penalties-cheered#main-content)

 Search Articles

- There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

Open main navigation

Close main navigation

- [Capabilities](https://www.countertax.ca/capabilities)
- Insights
  
  Show submenu for Insights
- [Case Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/case-studies)
- About
  
  Show submenu for About
- [Contact](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)

[![Counter Tax Litigators LLP](https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Imagery/CounterTax-logo.svg) ](https://www.countertax.ca/)

- [Capabilities](https://www.countertax.ca/capabilities)
- [Insights](https://www.countertax.ca/insights)
  
  Show submenu for Insights
- [Case Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/case-studies)
- [About](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/overview/institutional-history)
  
  Show submenu for About
- [Contact](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)

Open main navigation

Close main navigation

- [Capabilities](https://www.countertax.ca/capabilities)
- Insights
  
  Show submenu for Insights
- [Case Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/case-studies)
- About
  
  Show submenu for About
- [Contact](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)

![CounterTax](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Counter%20Tax%20Litigators%20Logo%20Stacked%20(MidnightBlue%20on%20White).jpg?width=120&name=Counter%20Tax%20Litigators%20Logo%20Stacked%20(MidnightBlue%20on%20White).jpg)

[Back to Insights](https://www.countertax.ca/insights)

### Related Insights

- [CRA Settlement After a Reassessment: When Resolution Becomes Unstable](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-settlement-after-a-reassessment-when-cra-keeps-pulling-the-file-back)
- [Dispute Record Risk at CRA Reassessment](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-dispute-record-risk)
- [Notice of Objection Failed to Define the Dispute](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-notice-of-objection-appea-limits)

# Decision reining in taxman’s penalties cheered

By  Counter Tax Litigators LLP

Share

- [![](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/images/linkedin-blue.png?width=20&name=linkedin-blue.png) LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://www.countertax.ca/insights/decision-reining-in-taxmans-penalties-cheered)
- [ X](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https://www.countertax.ca/insights/decision-reining-in-taxmans-penalties-cheered&text=)
- [email Email](mailto:info@countertax.ca?&subject=&cc=&bcc=&body=https://www.countertax.ca/insights/decision-reining-in-taxmans-penalties-cheered)

Print

![Decision reining in taxman’s penalties cheered](https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Thinking/countertax-thinking-2014-10-03.png)

Decision reining in taxman’s penalties cheered

7:28

##### [![The Bottom Line - Download Article](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Media/countertax-media-2014-09-TBL.jpg?width=320&name=countertax-media-2014-09-TBL.jpg)](https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Downloads/countertax-thinking-2014-10-03.pdf)

In a potentially precedent-setting case, the Tax Court of Canada has determined that the often “harsh” penalties imposed on taxpayers who misreport income in two out of four years cannot be imposed if due diligence is exercised in at least one of those years.

“This decision is a welcomed one as it sheds some light on the extent of the due diligence defence that is available to tax-payers and essentially provides an additional decision for tax-payers to rely on when faced with these penalties,” said Richard Weiland, a tax lawyer with Clark Wilson in Vancouver.

Toronto tax lawyer Peter Aprile is hoping the decision will persuade the minister of national revenue “to reconsider the routine imposition and dogged prosecution of a penalty that, in many cases, is disproportionate to the failure and exceeds other types of penalties that are designed to punish the most egregious conduct under the [tax] act.”

The court, in Galachiuk v. Canada [2014] T.C.J. No. 141, examined the application of a penalty under subsection 163(1) of the Income Tax Act. The penalty amounts to 10 per cent of the unreported income, plus another 10 per cent imposed at the provincial level.

“This often considerably exceeds the unpaid tax on the unreported income. As such, it has been described as a ‘harsh’ penalty by the Tax Court of Canada,” said Laurie Beausoleil, an associate in tax litigation with Wilson & Partners, a law firm affiliated with PwC LLP in Montreal.

In Galachiuk, the taxpayer failed to report $683 in the 2008 taxation year. However, in preparing his 2008 tax return, Robert Galachiuk, an Alberta resident, informed his investment advisers that he was moving to ensure that he received his T-slips at his new address, arranged with Canada Post to forward his mail, and carefully prepared his tax return.

“The court held that, in preparing his 2008 tax return, the taxpayer took reasonable precautions to avoid the failure and, therefore, established the he was duly diligent with respect to the 2008 taxation years,” said Peter Aprile, the principal of ATX Law in Toronto.

The following year, Galachiuk failed to report $436,890 and contended he was under the mistaken belief that his employer had reported all his income to the Canada Revenue Agency. However, he admitted that he did not review the relevant 2009 documents or appreciate that the T4A slips filed by his employer represented only 30 per cent of his income.

“The court commented that the taxpayer’s mistake of fact was not reasonable and, therefore, the taxpayer was not duly diligent in preparing his 2009 tax return,” said Aprile.

![It would be ironic if the government late-files a notice of appeal in a case in which the government argued that missed deadlines warrant a harsh penalty.](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Thinking/countertax-thinking-2014-10-03-quote1.png?width=822&height=480&name=countertax-thinking-2014-10-03-quote1.png "countertax-thinking-2014-10-03-quote1.png")

However, Justice David Graham found that due diligence in one year was sufficient to negate the imposition of a penalty. He adopted a broader approach to the question on the basis that if Parliament had wanted taxpayers to exercise due diligence every year it would have expressly limited the options available. Justice Graham also “emphasized that, contrary to common belief, the first failure does not seem to be intended to serve as a warning to the taxpayer,” Beausoleil observed.

The Tax Court’s finding is significant. Previous decisions on this issue have been inconsistent. “In at least two prior cases,” Weiland said, “the courts had held that due diligence had to be proven for the second offence; it was not sufficient to prove due diligence for the first offence.”

All the previous cases dealing with this issue were informal procedure cases, which cannot be used as a precedent in any other case. Galachiuk, however, is a general procedure case, the first subsection 163(1) case with precedential value. This increases the likelihood that it will carry weight with judges in the future, although this is not mandatory.

“The judges of the Tax Court are not strictly bound by the Galachiuk decision and could very well decide to distinguish this decision on its facts and reject a taxpayer’s due diligence defense in respect of a first failure,” Beausoleil said. “As such, Galachiuk does not completely settle the matter.”

Still given the precedential implications, the federal government may appeal, something that was atypical in previous cases.

Justice Graham acknowledged this likelihood in his decision. “I think that there is a reasonable chance that the Respondent may appeal my decision to the Federal Court of Appeal in order to obtain clarity on the interpretation of subsection 163(1),” he stated.

The formal deadline to appeal expired on July 10. However, Federal Court rules allow a party to late-file a notice of appeal. This second deadline expires this fall.

“It would be ironic if the government late-files a notice of appeal in a case in which the government argued that missed deadlines warrant a harsh penalty,” observed Aprile, a tax dispute resolution and litigation lawyer.

A decision of the Federal Court of Appeal on this matter, the next step in any appeal process, would provide more clarity and more certainty for the tax-payers since the Tax Court judges would be bound by its conclusions.

Many tax professionals believe victory in an appeal would be a victory for taxpayers.

“If this decision is sustained by the FCA, then it is good news for taxpayers,” said William Innes, a tax lawyer with Rueter Scargall Bennett in Toronto. “It would make it much more difficult for CRA to impose these penalties since they could not concentrate on only one taxation year.”

While the appeal question remains unsettled, accountants should take action in the wake of the court decision. The first is to be proactive in ensuring that all T-slips are received and tax returns carefully reviewed before filing. In addition, Aprile recommends reviewing the T-slips listed on the CRA’s “my account” online database prior to filing.

“Moreover, check notices of assessment carefully,” he said. “The CRA may add an unreported T-slip uncovered under the CRA matching program and add the amount to a notice of assessments. The tax-payer may have a first failure and not realize it is triggering a significant penalty on the second failure.”

If the reporting omission is first discovered by the taxpayer or the accountant, consider using the voluntary disclosure process to correct the tax filings, Weiland said. “A successful voluntary disclosure will allow the taxpayer to avoid the penalties.”

A T1-Adjustment Request should also be filed. If this is done, Aprile said, CRA policy dictates the omission will not be considered under ss. 163(1).

If the CRA uncovers the over-sight first, a notice of objection should be filed and not an application to the minister of national revenue’s fairness committee, said David Sohmer, a founding partner of Spiegel Sohmer, a Montreal-based law firm.

“The courts can only send a refusal to grant relief back to the minister for reconsideration if the minister’s decision is unreasonable, but the Tax Court can overturn a penalty by finding due diligence,” he said.

“Many tax advisers ask for relief first, and when it is refused, it is too late to file a notice of objection.” 

 

For additional analysis, see our [Insights](https://www.countertax.ca/insights).

## Insights

[![CRA Settlement After a Reassessment: When Resolution Becomes Unstable | Zhang v. HMK illustrates how resolution may not be treated as final inside the institution](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/CRA%20Settlement%20After%20a%20Reassessment%20When%20Resolution%20Becomes%20Unstable.png?width=499&height=299&name=CRA%20Settlement%20After%20a%20Reassessment%20When%20Resolution%20Becomes%20Unstable.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-settlement-after-a-reassessment-when-cra-keeps-pulling-the-file-back)

### [CRA Settlement After a Reassessment: When Resolution Becomes Unstable](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-settlement-after-a-reassessment-when-cra-keeps-pulling-the-file-back)

*Tax Court of Canada decision on CRA settlement after reassessment, showing how accepted settlement terms may not end the dispute when CRA and DOJ continue pulling the file back. (Zhang v HMK)*

[![](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Dispute%20Record%20Risk%20at%20CRA%20Reassessment.png?width=499&height=299&name=Dispute%20Record%20Risk%20at%20CRA%20Reassessment.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-dispute-record-risk)

### [Dispute Record Risk at CRA Reassessment](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-dispute-record-risk)

*A CRA reassessment and dispute do not start from a neutral position. They shape the dispute, now and later. This article explains how the record develops and the impact on teh range of outcomes. *

[![Notice of Objection Failed to Define the Dispute | Some objection-stage failures are obvious. Others remain invisible and lead to the same result. (941624 Alberta Ltd. v. HMK) ](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/2026-04-20%20Notice%20of%20Objection%20Failed%20to%20Define%20the%20Dispute.png?width=499&height=299&name=2026-04-20%20Notice%20of%20Objection%20Failed%20to%20Define%20the%20Dispute.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-notice-of-objection-appea-limits)

### [Notice of Objection Failed to Define the Dispute](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-notice-of-objection-appea-limits)

*CRA reassessment and notice of objection. Large corporation regime. How a failure to define the dispute can stop an appeal early or narrow what can be argued later.*

[![Cross-Border Rental & Withholding Reassessment Control - When the structure holds, and where it can still be moved -  C&W Offshore Ltd. v. HMK ](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Cross-Border%20Rental%20%26%20Withholding%20Reassessment%20Control.png?width=499&height=299&name=Cross-Border%20Rental%20%26%20Withholding%20Reassessment%20Control.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cross-border-rental-withholding-tax-reassessment)

### [Cross-Border Rental & Withholding Reassessment Control](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cross-border-rental-withholding-tax-reassessment)

*A cross-border equipment rental led to a withholding tax reassessment under Part XIII. This case shows how much of the exposure can still be reduced when the structure holds.*

[![DAC Investment Holdings and the Widening Lens on Tax Regime Integrity](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/DAC%20Investment%20Holdings%20and%20the%20Widening%20Lens%20on%20Tax%20Regime%20Integrity.png?width=499&height=299&name=DAC%20Investment%20Holdings%20and%20the%20Widening%20Lens%20on%20Tax%20Regime%20Integrity.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/dac-fca-gaar-ccpc)

### [DAC Investment Holdings and the Widening Lens on Tax Regime Integrity](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/dac-fca-gaar-ccpc)

*Federal Court of Appeal decision in DAC Investment Holdings (2026 FCA 35) shows how GAAR disputes can turn on tax regime integrity rather than individual provisions.*

[![Bakorp Confirms That Large Corporation Objections Define the Outcome | How subsection 165(1.11) limited the appeal before the tax issue was ever examined](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Bakorp%20Confirms%20That%20Large%20Corporation%20Objections%20Define%20the%20Outcome.png?width=499&height=299&name=Bakorp%20Confirms%20That%20Large%20Corporation%20Objections%20Define%20the%20Outcome.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/bakorp-large-corporation-objection-limits)

### [Bakorp Confirms That Large Corporation Objections Define the Outcome](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/bakorp-large-corporation-objection-limits)

*In Bakorp, the FCA held that subsection 165(1.11) confines a large corporation’s appeal to the issues specified in its Notice of Objection, dismissing the case without reviewing the tax merits.*

[ Explore more insights > ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights)

- Capabilities 
    - [Capabilities Overview](https://www.countertax.ca/capabilities)
- Insights 
    - [Insights Overview](https://www.countertax.ca/insights)
    - [CRA Dispute Decision Points](https://www.countertax.ca/cra-dispute-decision-points)
    - [Tax Dispute Caselaw & Signals](https://www.countertax.ca/tax-dispute-caselaw-signals)
    - [Foundations](https://www.countertax.ca/foundations)
    - [Case Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/case-studies)
    - [Institute for Tax Controversy Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/institute/overview)
- About 
    - [About Overview](https://www.countertax.ca/institute/about-us)
    - [History](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/overview/institutional-history)
    - [Partners](https://www.countertax.ca/partners)
    - [Governance & Standards](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/overview/governance)
    - [The Work](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/overview/standard-of-the-work)
    - [Recognition](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/recognition)

##### Contact

[Begin here](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)

[![Counter-Newsletter-linkedin-icon-navy-lg](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Counter_Tax/email/Counter-Newsletter-linkedin-icon-navy-lg.png?width=34&height=34&name=Counter-Newsletter-linkedin-icon-navy-lg.png)](https://www.linkedin.com/company/counter-tax-lawyers/)

##### Subscribe to receive CRA reassessment and dispute insights

 © Counter Tax Litigators 2026

- Chambers Global
- Chambers Canada
- International Tax Review

- [Contact](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)
- [Terms of Use](https://www.countertax.ca/terms-of-use)
- [Privacy Policy](https://www.countertax.ca/privacy-policy)
- [Disclaimer](https://www.countertax.ca/disclaimer)

![](https://px.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=6846258&fmt=gif)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP",
    "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca/insights/author/counter"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-04-30T14:40:38.129Z",
  "datePublished" : "2014-10-03T04:00:00.000Z",
  "headline" : "Decision reining in taxman’s penalties cheered",
  "image" : [ "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Thinking/countertax-thinking-2014-10-03.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.countertax.ca/insights/decision-reining-in-taxmans-penalties-cheered",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Branding/countertax-logo-white.svg"
    },
    "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators"
  }
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@id" : "https://www.countertax.ca/#legalservice",
  "@type" : [ "LegalService", "Organization" ],
  "address" : {
    "@type" : "PostalAddress",
    "addressCountry" : "CA",
    "addressLocality" : "Toronto",
    "addressRegion" : "ON",
    "postalCode" : "M4V 3A9",
    "streetAddress" : "301–10 Alcorn Avenue"
  },
  "alternateName" : "Counter LLP",
  "award" : [ "Included in ITR World Tax 2026 Tax Controversy Rankings", "Recognized in Chambers Canada 2026 for Tax Litigation", "Recognized among Canada's Top Tax Law Boutiques by Canadian Lawyer (2025–2026)", "Recognized in ITR World Tax 2025 Rankings for Tax Controversy (Canada)", "Finalist for Tax Innovator of the Year by International Tax Review" ],
  "description" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP acts exclusively for private companies in material judgment-driven CRA disputes. Engagement begins at reassessment and operates through resolution.",
  "founder" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.countertax.ca/partners/peter-aprile#person",
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Peter Aprile",
    "sameAs" : [ "https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q139586811", "https://www.linkedin.com/in/peteraprile", "https://chambers.com/lawyer/peter-aprile-global-2:25392815" ],
    "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca/partners/peter-aprile"
  },
  "image" : [ {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/CRA%20Objection%20Strategy%20Article.jpg",
    "description" : "Explore key considerations for selecting the most effective approach to the CRA’s objection process, balancing full engagement with strategic disengagement.",
    "name" : "CRA’s Objection Process: Full Engagement vs. Strategic Disengagement"
  }, {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Winning%20Settlements%20in%20CRA%20Tax%20Disputes%20Article.jpg",
    "description" : "Strategic settlement design aligns client goals with legal principles to achieve superior outcomes.",
    "name" : "Winning Settlements: Aligning Client Goals with Legal Strategy."
  }, {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Comprehensive%20Analysis%20of%20Income%20Tax%20Penalties%20Article.jpg",
    "description" : "A Comprehensive Analysis of Income Tax Penalties, clarity and superior tax dispute results provided by Counter Tax Litigators LLP.",
    "name" : "A Comprehensive Analysis of Income Tax Penalties"
  }, {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Overturning%20CRA%20Non-Resident%20Trusts.jpg",
    "description" : "Read Canada’s trusted guide to addressing CRA challenges to non-resident trusts, published by Counter Tax Litigators LLP x Thomson Reuters.",
    "name" : "Overturning CRA Decisions on Non-Resident Trusts"
  }, {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Corporate%20Residence%20Article%20Image.jpg",
    "description" : "Canada’s leading guide on complex corporate residence disputes, published by CounterTax Litigators LLP x Thomson Reuters.",
    "name" : "A Comprehensive Guide to Corporate Residence and Disputes in Canada"
  } ],
  "knowsAbout" : [ "Tax litigation", "Tax controversy", "CRA disputes", "Tax reassessments", "Objection-stage tax disputes", "Tax appeals" ],
  "legalName" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP",
  "logo" : {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Counter%20Tax%20Litigators%20Logo%20Stacked%20(MidnightBlue%20on%20White).jpg",
    "description" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP logo with tagline, emphasizing expertise in tax litigation.",
    "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators Logo"
  },
  "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP",
  "sameAs" : [ "https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q139032486", "https://www.linkedin.com/company/counter-tax-litigators/", "https://chambers.com/law-firm/counter-tax-litigators-llp-canada-20:22876595", "https://www.itrworldtax.com/Firm/Counter-Tax-Litigators-Canada/Profile/39298", "https://www.legal500.com/firms/240684-counter-tax-litigators-llp/239668-toronto-canada/" ],
  "telephone" : "+1-416-218-5263",
  "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca/"
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@id" : "https://www.countertax.ca/#website",
  "@type" : "WebSite",
  "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators",
  "potentialAction" : {
    "@type" : "SearchAction",
    "query-input" : "required name=search_term_string",
    "target" : "https://www.countertax.ca/search-results?q={search_term_string}"
  },
  "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca"
}
```