---
title: Hidden Tax Risks in Corporate Life Insurance | Counter Tax Litigators LLP
description: Counter LLP’s tax litigation experts, Peter Aprile and James Roberts, break down how corporate life insurance premiums can lead to hidden tax risks - and what business leaders can do to stay ahead.
image: https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/CaseLaw_Insights_Pattern_Purple%26Green.jpg
---

[Skip to content](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-scrutiny-how-executives-take-control#main-content)

 Search Articles

- There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

Open main navigation

Close main navigation

- [Capabilities](https://www.countertax.ca/capabilities)
- Insights
  
  Show submenu for Insights
- [Case Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/case-studies)
- About
  
  Show submenu for About
- [Contact](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)

[![Counter Tax Litigators LLP](https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Imagery/CounterTax-logo.svg) ](https://www.countertax.ca/)

- [Capabilities](https://www.countertax.ca/capabilities)
- [Insights](https://www.countertax.ca/insights)
  
  Show submenu for Insights
- [Case Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/case-studies)
- [About](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/overview/institutional-history)
  
  Show submenu for About
- [Contact](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)

Open main navigation

Close main navigation

- [Capabilities](https://www.countertax.ca/capabilities)
- Insights
  
  Show submenu for Insights
- [Case Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/case-studies)
- About
  
  Show submenu for About
- [Contact](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)

![CounterTax](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Counter%20Tax%20Litigators%20Logo%20Stacked%20(MidnightBlue%20on%20White).jpg?width=120&name=Counter%20Tax%20Litigators%20Logo%20Stacked%20(MidnightBlue%20on%20White).jpg)

[Back to Insights](https://www.countertax.ca/insights)

### Related Insights

- [CRA Settlement After a Reassessment: When Resolution Becomes Unstable](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-settlement-after-a-reassessment-when-cra-keeps-pulling-the-file-back)
- [Dispute Record Risk at CRA Reassessment](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-dispute-record-risk)
- [Notice of Objection Failed to Define the Dispute](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-notice-of-objection-appea-limits)

# Hidden Tax Risks in Corporate Life Insurance

 CRA Scrutiny Is Increasing – And How Executives Can Take Control Now

By  Counter Tax Litigators LLP

Share

- [![](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/images/linkedin-blue.png?width=20&name=linkedin-blue.png) LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-scrutiny-how-executives-take-control)
- [ X](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-scrutiny-how-executives-take-control&text=)
- [email Email](mailto:info@countertax.ca?&subject=&cc=&bcc=&body=https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-scrutiny-how-executives-take-control)

Print

![Hidden Tax Risks in Corporate Life Insurance](https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/CaseLaw_Insights_Pattern_Purple%26Green.jpg)

Hidden Tax Risks in Corporate Life Insurance

4:53

#### Executive Summary

A recent ruling by the Federal Court of Appeal in [*Gestion M.-A. Roy Inc. v Canada*](https://decisions.fca-caf.gc.ca/fca-caf/decisions/fr/item/521327/index.do), 2024 CAF 16, underscores a growing risk in corporate tax planning: life insurance premiums paid by one entity for a policy held by another can create unintended taxable benefits—even when structured for legitimate business purposes.

The decision reaffirms the Canada Revenue Agency’s (CRA) broad interpretation of benefit conferral, highlighting that taxable benefits arise based on payment structure, not intent. This signals heightened scrutiny for corporate-owned life insurance arrangements and the increasing application of subsection 246(1) of the *Income Tax Act *beyond direct shareholder relationships.

#### Key Takeaways: What Taxpayers Need to Know

1. Premium payments create a taxable benefit when the payer is not the policyholder.

- The courts reaffirmed that an operating company (Opco) paying premiums for life insurance policies held by two holding companies (Holdcos) resulted in taxable benefits – even though Opco was the revocable beneficiary.
- Intent does not override structure – even if the policy was meant to fund a buyout, the courts focused on who paid rather than why the policy existed.

1. The CRA’s application of subsection 246(1) is expanding.

- The CRA assessed a taxable benefit under subsection 15(1) for Holdco, a shareholder, a well-established approach.
- More notably, CRA applied subsection 246(1) to a non-shareholder Holdco, reinforcing a broader interpretation that any economic benefit conferred – even indirectly – can trigger taxation.
- This expansion signals increased scrutiny on intercorporate life insurance arrangements.

1. Businesses must reassess life insurance structures to prevent taxable benefit exposure.

- Buy-sell insurance arrangements need careful review. If an Opco is paying the premiums, there is a heightened risk of taxable benefit assessments—even when structured for succession planning.
- Holding companies and subsidiaries face increased risk. If a subsidiary pays for a policy owned by a parent (or vice versa), the CRA is likely to assess a benefit under subsection 246(1).
- Future disputes may test CRA’s interpretation. Given the broad application of 246(1), there may be opportunities to challenge assessments where the economic benefit is unclear.

#### Case Summary: The Dispute That Led to This Ruling

*The Taxpayer*: Marc-André Roy, the majority shareholder of R3D Conseil Inc. (R3D), held shares indirectly through two holding companies.

*The Tax Plan*: The holding companies purchased life insurance policies to fund a buy-sell agreement. R3D was named as the revocable beneficiary, but R3D paid the policy premiums over four years.

*The CRA’s Position*: The Agency argued that the holding companies received a taxable benefit equal to the premiums paid. The CRA assessed:

- a direct taxable benefit (subsection 15(1)) to the shareholder Holdco; and
- an indirect taxable benefit (subsection 246(1)) to the non-shareholder Holdco.

*The Court’s Decision*: The FCA upheld that a taxable benefit arose under subsections 15(1) and 246(1), reaffirming CRA’s broad interpretation of economic benefit.

#### The Larger Tax and Insurance Planning Implications

The FCA’s ruling reinforces a key shift in corporate tax enforcement: economic benefit trumps commercial intent. Regardless of why a structure exists, the CRA and courts focus on payment mechanics – a critical distinction for taxpayers structuring corporate life insurance.

Moving forward:

- Taxpayers must prioritize tax-efficient structures over business-driven decisions.
- Holding companies should avoid structures where subsidiaries pay the premiums.
- Legal challenges to subsection 246(1) may be necessary to push back against CRA’s broad application.

#### Final Thoughts

The FCA’s ruling highlights the growing tax risks in corporate-owned life insurance. With CRA’s expanded use of subsection 246(1) and a continued focus on payment structures, businesses must reassess existing arrangements to avoid unexpected taxable benefits.

Sophistic taxpayers must position themselves for success long before CRA scrutiny until more precise guidance emerges. By mitigating risk, shaping the narrative, and establishing the proper groundwork early, decision-makers position themselves for the best outcome in these cases.

As with any challenge or risk, the people who take control early achieve the best outcomes. It’s not just about responding – it’s about setting the terms before the conflict begins.

[![Speak with Peter and James about this article](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/449501/0d57ae56-7146-499b-9e83-e87a9a7d2aa4.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/449501/0d57ae56-7146-499b-9e83-e87a9a7d2aa4)

[Gestion M.-A. Roy Inc. v Canada, 2024 CAF 16](https://decisions.fca-caf.gc.ca/fca-caf/decisions/fr/item/521327/index.do).

 

 

For additional analysis, see our [Insights](https://www.countertax.ca/insights).

## Insights

[![CRA Settlement After a Reassessment: When Resolution Becomes Unstable | Zhang v. HMK illustrates how resolution may not be treated as final inside the institution](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/CRA%20Settlement%20After%20a%20Reassessment%20When%20Resolution%20Becomes%20Unstable.png?width=499&height=299&name=CRA%20Settlement%20After%20a%20Reassessment%20When%20Resolution%20Becomes%20Unstable.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-settlement-after-a-reassessment-when-cra-keeps-pulling-the-file-back)

### [CRA Settlement After a Reassessment: When Resolution Becomes Unstable](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-settlement-after-a-reassessment-when-cra-keeps-pulling-the-file-back)

*Tax Court of Canada decision on CRA settlement after reassessment, showing how accepted settlement terms may not end the dispute when CRA and DOJ continue pulling the file back. (Zhang v HMK)*

[![](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Dispute%20Record%20Risk%20at%20CRA%20Reassessment.png?width=499&height=299&name=Dispute%20Record%20Risk%20at%20CRA%20Reassessment.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-dispute-record-risk)

### [Dispute Record Risk at CRA Reassessment](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-dispute-record-risk)

*A CRA reassessment and dispute do not start from a neutral position. They shape the dispute, now and later. This article explains how the record develops and the impact on teh range of outcomes. *

[![Notice of Objection Failed to Define the Dispute | Some objection-stage failures are obvious. Others remain invisible and lead to the same result. (941624 Alberta Ltd. v. HMK) ](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/2026-04-20%20Notice%20of%20Objection%20Failed%20to%20Define%20the%20Dispute.png?width=499&height=299&name=2026-04-20%20Notice%20of%20Objection%20Failed%20to%20Define%20the%20Dispute.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-notice-of-objection-appea-limits)

### [Notice of Objection Failed to Define the Dispute](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-reassessment-notice-of-objection-appea-limits)

*CRA reassessment and notice of objection. Large corporation regime. How a failure to define the dispute can stop an appeal early or narrow what can be argued later.*

[![Cross-Border Rental & Withholding Reassessment Control - When the structure holds, and where it can still be moved -  C&W Offshore Ltd. v. HMK ](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Cross-Border%20Rental%20%26%20Withholding%20Reassessment%20Control.png?width=499&height=299&name=Cross-Border%20Rental%20%26%20Withholding%20Reassessment%20Control.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cross-border-rental-withholding-tax-reassessment)

### [Cross-Border Rental & Withholding Reassessment Control](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cross-border-rental-withholding-tax-reassessment)

*A cross-border equipment rental led to a withholding tax reassessment under Part XIII. This case shows how much of the exposure can still be reduced when the structure holds.*

[![DAC Investment Holdings and the Widening Lens on Tax Regime Integrity](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/DAC%20Investment%20Holdings%20and%20the%20Widening%20Lens%20on%20Tax%20Regime%20Integrity.png?width=499&height=299&name=DAC%20Investment%20Holdings%20and%20the%20Widening%20Lens%20on%20Tax%20Regime%20Integrity.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/dac-fca-gaar-ccpc)

### [DAC Investment Holdings and the Widening Lens on Tax Regime Integrity](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/dac-fca-gaar-ccpc)

*Federal Court of Appeal decision in DAC Investment Holdings (2026 FCA 35) shows how GAAR disputes can turn on tax regime integrity rather than individual provisions.*

[![Bakorp Confirms That Large Corporation Objections Define the Outcome | How subsection 165(1.11) limited the appeal before the tax issue was ever examined](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Bakorp%20Confirms%20That%20Large%20Corporation%20Objections%20Define%20the%20Outcome.png?width=499&height=299&name=Bakorp%20Confirms%20That%20Large%20Corporation%20Objections%20Define%20the%20Outcome.png) ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/bakorp-large-corporation-objection-limits)

### [Bakorp Confirms That Large Corporation Objections Define the Outcome](https://www.countertax.ca/insights/bakorp-large-corporation-objection-limits)

*In Bakorp, the FCA held that subsection 165(1.11) confines a large corporation’s appeal to the issues specified in its Notice of Objection, dismissing the case without reviewing the tax merits.*

[ Explore more insights > ](https://www.countertax.ca/insights)

- Capabilities 
    - [Capabilities Overview](https://www.countertax.ca/capabilities)
- Insights 
    - [Insights Overview](https://www.countertax.ca/insights)
    - [CRA Dispute Decision Points](https://www.countertax.ca/cra-dispute-decision-points)
    - [Tax Dispute Caselaw & Signals](https://www.countertax.ca/tax-dispute-caselaw-signals)
    - [Foundations](https://www.countertax.ca/foundations)
    - [Case Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/case-studies)
    - [Institute for Tax Controversy Studies](https://www.countertax.ca/institute/overview)
- About 
    - [About Overview](https://www.countertax.ca/institute/about-us)
    - [History](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/overview/institutional-history)
    - [Partners](https://www.countertax.ca/partners)
    - [Governance & Standards](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/overview/governance)
    - [The Work](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/overview/standard-of-the-work)
    - [Recognition](https://www.countertax.ca/about-us/recognition)

##### Contact

[Begin here](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)

[![Counter-Newsletter-linkedin-icon-navy-lg](https://www.countertax.ca/hs-fs/hubfs/Counter_Tax/email/Counter-Newsletter-linkedin-icon-navy-lg.png?width=34&height=34&name=Counter-Newsletter-linkedin-icon-navy-lg.png)](https://www.linkedin.com/company/counter-tax-lawyers/)

##### Subscribe to receive CRA reassessment and dispute insights

 © Counter Tax Litigators 2026

- Chambers Global
- Chambers Canada
- International Tax Review

- [Contact](https://www.countertax.ca/contact)
- [Terms of Use](https://www.countertax.ca/terms-of-use)
- [Privacy Policy](https://www.countertax.ca/privacy-policy)
- [Disclaimer](https://www.countertax.ca/disclaimer)

![](https://px.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=6846258&fmt=gif)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP",
    "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca/insights/author/counter"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-06-24T17:04:10.843Z",
  "datePublished" : "2024-02-11T12:30:00.000Z",
  "headline" : "Hidden Tax Risks in Corporate Life Insurance",
  "image" : [ "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/CaseLaw_Insights_Pattern_Purple&Green.jpg" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.countertax.ca/insights/cra-scrutiny-how-executives-take-control",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Countertax_2016/Branding/countertax-logo-white.svg"
    },
    "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators"
  }
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@id" : "https://www.countertax.ca/#legalservice",
  "@type" : [ "LegalService", "Organization" ],
  "address" : {
    "@type" : "PostalAddress",
    "addressCountry" : "CA",
    "addressLocality" : "Toronto",
    "addressRegion" : "ON",
    "postalCode" : "M4V 3A9",
    "streetAddress" : "301–10 Alcorn Avenue"
  },
  "alternateName" : "Counter LLP",
  "award" : [ "Included in ITR World Tax 2026 Tax Controversy Rankings", "Recognized in Chambers Canada 2026 for Tax Litigation", "Recognized among Canada's Top Tax Law Boutiques by Canadian Lawyer (2025–2026)", "Recognized in ITR World Tax 2025 Rankings for Tax Controversy (Canada)", "Finalist for Tax Innovator of the Year by International Tax Review" ],
  "description" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP acts exclusively for private companies in material judgment-driven CRA disputes. Engagement begins at reassessment and operates through resolution.",
  "founder" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.countertax.ca/partners/peter-aprile#person",
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Peter Aprile",
    "sameAs" : [ "https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q139586811", "https://www.linkedin.com/in/peteraprile", "https://chambers.com/lawyer/peter-aprile-global-2:25392815" ],
    "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca/partners/peter-aprile"
  },
  "image" : [ {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/CRA%20Objection%20Strategy%20Article.jpg",
    "description" : "Explore key considerations for selecting the most effective approach to the CRA’s objection process, balancing full engagement with strategic disengagement.",
    "name" : "CRA’s Objection Process: Full Engagement vs. Strategic Disengagement"
  }, {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Winning%20Settlements%20in%20CRA%20Tax%20Disputes%20Article.jpg",
    "description" : "Strategic settlement design aligns client goals with legal principles to achieve superior outcomes.",
    "name" : "Winning Settlements: Aligning Client Goals with Legal Strategy."
  }, {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Comprehensive%20Analysis%20of%20Income%20Tax%20Penalties%20Article.jpg",
    "description" : "A Comprehensive Analysis of Income Tax Penalties, clarity and superior tax dispute results provided by Counter Tax Litigators LLP.",
    "name" : "A Comprehensive Analysis of Income Tax Penalties"
  }, {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Overturning%20CRA%20Non-Resident%20Trusts.jpg",
    "description" : "Read Canada’s trusted guide to addressing CRA challenges to non-resident trusts, published by Counter Tax Litigators LLP x Thomson Reuters.",
    "name" : "Overturning CRA Decisions on Non-Resident Trusts"
  }, {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Corporate%20Residence%20Article%20Image.jpg",
    "description" : "Canada’s leading guide on complex corporate residence disputes, published by CounterTax Litigators LLP x Thomson Reuters.",
    "name" : "A Comprehensive Guide to Corporate Residence and Disputes in Canada"
  } ],
  "knowsAbout" : [ "Tax litigation", "Tax controversy", "CRA disputes", "Tax reassessments", "Objection-stage tax disputes", "Tax appeals" ],
  "legalName" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP",
  "logo" : {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "contentUrl" : "https://www.countertax.ca/hubfs/Counter-Tax-Theme/Schema%20Images/Counter%20Tax%20Litigators%20Logo%20Stacked%20(MidnightBlue%20on%20White).jpg",
    "description" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP logo with tagline, emphasizing expertise in tax litigation.",
    "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators Logo"
  },
  "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators LLP",
  "sameAs" : [ "https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q139032486", "https://www.linkedin.com/company/counter-tax-litigators/", "https://chambers.com/law-firm/counter-tax-litigators-llp-canada-20:22876595", "https://www.itrworldtax.com/Firm/Counter-Tax-Litigators-Canada/Profile/39298", "https://www.legal500.com/firms/240684-counter-tax-litigators-llp/239668-toronto-canada/" ],
  "telephone" : "+1-416-218-5263",
  "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca/"
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@id" : "https://www.countertax.ca/#website",
  "@type" : "WebSite",
  "name" : "Counter Tax Litigators",
  "potentialAction" : {
    "@type" : "SearchAction",
    "query-input" : "required name=search_term_string",
    "target" : "https://www.countertax.ca/search-results?q={search_term_string}"
  },
  "url" : "https://www.countertax.ca"
}
```